The Toothache Christ of St Stephen's Cathedral, Vienna

The short answer: round the back of St Stephen's Cathedral, on the outside wall of the east end, there's a niche holding a stone half-length figure of Christ that the Viennese call the Zahnwehherrgott, Our Lord of the Toothache. Legend has it that a young nobleman laughed at the figure because it had a cloth tied round its chin, like someone with a swollen jaw, and paid for the joke with a toothache that wouldn't let up until he went back and begged forgiveness on his knees. The figure is medieval, from around 1400. The legend, according to the City of Vienna's own history encyclopaedia, only appeared in the nineteenth century. And that cloth, according to the encyclopaedia and the folklorist who collected the legend, was never a toothache bandage at all: it was a ribbon for holding flowers.

Outside niche at St Stephen's Cathedral in Vienna with the stone half-length figure known as the Toothache Christ

What is the Zahnwehherrgott?

The German name splits neatly in two: Zahnweh, toothache, and Herrgott, Our Lord. It's what the Viennese call a stone half-length figure showing Christ as an Ecce Homo: the moment in the Gospel when Pilate brings him out before the crowd, already scourged, and says "Behold the man". It's an image of suffering, meant to move people to pity, not to laughter.

It sits in what's known as the Poor Souls' Niche (Armenseelennische), on the outside of the choir, that's to say at the east end of the church, behind the high altar. The sources don't quite agree on the date: the city's entry for the figure itself says fifteenth century, while its entry for the cathedral puts it at around 1400. Either way, it's a medieval piece. What you see in the niche today, though, is a copy made in the 1960s.

What does the legend say?

The classic version is the one Gustav Gugitz included in his collection of Viennese legends, published in 1952. A young nobleman was riding past the cathedral with his drinking and gambling companions, all in high spirits. He noticed the figure, and one detail in particular: round Christ's chin there was a faded pink ribbon, there to hold the crown of flowers that always decorated his head. Tied like that, it looked just like the cloth people knotted round their face when they had toothache.

The nobleman couldn't resist. He christened the figure Our Lord of the Toothache, and his friends roared with laughter.

That very day he was seized by an agonising toothache that no doctor's remedy could touch. It only eased when he went back to the figure, knelt in repentance and apologised for mocking it. From then on, Gugitz concludes, the statue kept its nickname, and people turned to it to be spared ailments of the mouth.

It's a legend with a very clear moral: don't make fun of what's sacred. And the punishment fits the crime rather neatly: he sinned with his mouth and paid for it in his mouth.

How old is the legend?

Here's the surprise. The city's history encyclopaedia, the Wien Geschichte Wiki, drawing on Gugitz, says the legend was born in the nineteenth century. If the figure dates from around 1400, this Christ went roughly four centuries without a twinge. The nickname and the story arrived long after the stone.

We haven't been able to find the first printed version, and we don't know who first told it. But it's not hard to see how it happened. Someone used to decorate the figure with flowers and tie a ribbon under the chin to keep them in place. In time, nobody remembered what the ribbon was for, and it started to look like something else. And when a city no longer understands a detail, it comes up with an explanation. This one even came with a lesson attached.

A word of caution: the ribbon isn't proved by any document from 1400 either. It's the explanation given by Gugitz and the city encyclopaedia, and it fits what you can see, but it's an interpretation of the detail, not a record.

A legend that keeps on growing

The more a legend is told, the more details it picks up, and this one's a fine example. In 1997 the author Elisabeth Jaindl published a book in Vienna about the cathedral, with a far more elaborate version.

In hers, pious women tie the flower crown under Christ's chin with silk ribbons so the wind, which is forever blowing round the cathedral, won't carry it off. The mockers are no longer a nameless nobleman and his crowd, but three young noblemen, drinking pals with names of their own: Diepold, Georg and Wendelin. One shouts that Our Lord has toothache; the second says no wonder, standing in a draught all year; the third suggests they'll have to pull the tooth. That night Diepold can't sleep for the pain. He tries schnapps, to no avail, and they send for none other than Paracelsus, the famous sixteenth-century physician. The doctor can't find a cause, and tells him he's the third man in Vienna that day with the same complaint; only God can cure it. All three end up on their knees before the figure, while passers-by laugh at the sight of the town's best-known drunks at prayer, and the pain vanishes.

Notice what's crept in between one version and the next: the wind, the names, the schnapps and a celebrated doctor. None of that is in Gugitz.

What's true about the Poor Souls' corner?

Quite a lot, even if it isn't the punishment. The niche is named after the poor souls because it invites prayer for the dead. That's no accident: for centuries the cathedral was surrounded by its graveyard, which stayed in use until 1732. In 1783 the graves were cleared, and the most notable gravestones ended up set into the church walls.

Behind the figure is a painting of the Virgin interceding for the souls, by Josef Danhauser, from 1826, so a good deal later than the Christ. The niche also holds three reliefs of the Passion, probably from the early fifteenth century. Close by, further along the outside wall, is the pulpit from which the Franciscan friar John of Capistrano preached in 1451 to raise a crusade against the Turks, and the chapel where Mozart's body was blessed on 6 December 1791.

It was in that graveyard, incidentally, that Kolschitzky was given a pauper's burial, the man tradition credits with Vienna's first coffee house; his story, and the one about the sacks of Turkish coffee, is told in the Vienna coffee house legend.

So this one corner stacks up the centuries: a medieval figure replaced by a copy, a nineteenth-century painting, an old graveyard and a late legend that explains the lot with a toothache. And a few steps away, on the corner of Kärntner Straße, another odd object has a legend of its own, with the Devil involved: the Stock im Eisen, Vienna's nail tree.

Fact or legend.

  • Legend: the nobleman who mocks the figure and suffers toothache until he asks forgiveness. According to Vienna's history encyclopaedia, it dates from the nineteenth century.
  • Fact: the figure is a stone half-length Ecce Homo, medieval (around 1400, or fifteenth century, depending on which entry you read).
  • Fact: what you see in the niche today is a 1960s copy.
  • The sources' interpretation: the "cloth" was a ribbon holding a crown of flowers, which looked like a toothache bandage.
  • Fact: Danhauser's painting dates from 1826, and the cathedral was surrounded by a graveyard until 1732.
  • Modern embellishment: the three named drinking pals, the wind and Paracelsus appear in a version published in 1997.

Where to hear it

Podtour tells this story by the cathedral's east end, at the stop "The Christ of Toothache" on the route Legends of Old Vienna, twelve stops that sort legend from record. The route finishes close by, with "The Tree Trunk Full of Nails".

If you're planning your trip, the Vienna guide has the practical side covered.

Further reading

Explore with Podtour

Where to hear this story

Keep exploring

Plan your time in Vienna

Explore ViennaTravel guide

Take the stories
with you.

Download Podtour for free and start with the free walk in every city. Your pace, your next stop.