Why are Neapolitan nativity scenes full of ordinary people? Charles III and San Gregorio Armeno
The short answer: because in the eighteenth century, Neapolitan sculptors put aside the models of the academies and copied living people instead, above all the country folk around Naples, in their own clothes. The habit of surrounding the Nativity with every kind of everyday life was older, but the great boom came with Charles of Bourbon, the king who would later become Charles III of Spain. He turned the presepe, as the Neapolitan nativity scene is called, into a passion at court, to the point where the queen sewed clothes for the figures with her own hands. That's where everything in the shop windows of San Gregorio Armeno comes from: traders, poultry, baskets of fruit and, if you look hard enough, a baby in a manger.

Why is a Neapolitan nativity scene so full of ordinary people?
In 1935 the Enciclopedia Italiana, Italy's great national encyclopaedia, ran a long article on the nativity scene, and its explanation still holds up. The presepe was made to teach the faith and to make the onlooker feel part of the scene, and that pushes it towards realism. It also has a problem of composition: the Christ Child has to stay at the centre, yet the whole point of the scene is served by surrounding him with all kinds of life.
That life around the edges had a religious meaning. It expressed the idea that the miracle hadn't been revealed to everyone: while something extraordinary happens in the cave, the world carries on with its shopping, its inns and its flocks. And it contrasted the humble birth with the luxury of worldly life. According to the encyclopaedia, these themes were especially popular in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, perhaps first in Sicily, then in Rome and Naples, where by the early 1700s the presepe had already taken on its characteristic form.
Where does the Neapolitan presepe come from?
From long before the Bourbons. The nativity scene wasn't invented by the Franciscans: it grew out of the liturgical performances of Christmas Eve, which gave Saint Francis the idea for his own at Greccio. Franciscans, Dominicans and later Jesuits spread it, first in churches and only later in people's homes. The oldest surviving one, in part, is by Arnolfo di Cambio, in Santa Maria Maggiore in Rome.
It reached Naples, perhaps from Tuscany, in the last quarter of the fifteenth century. The partly surviving presepe in the church of San Giovanni a Carbonara dates from 1484, with wooden figures and even prophets and sibyls. In the south, a model of its own won out: a mountain with the cave, the shepherds and, higher up, the procession of the Three Kings. That way the figures and side scenes could multiply without needing much depth.
Wooden figures were expensive, and many were replaced by mannequins dressed in fabric, with only the head modelled. In late seventeenth-century Naples, those little heads started to be made of clay, with glass eyes, and wood was kept for the hands and feet, which broke more easily. Still lifes, hens, sheep and pigs were made in clay too. Well-known sculptors such as Lorenzo Vaccaro were already working on nativity figures before the king arrived.
What did Charles III have to do with it?
Charles of Bourbon entered Naples in 1734, aged eighteen, as the kingdom's first king of its own after two centuries of viceroys. The Enciclopedia Italiana describes him as deeply religious, drawn to family life and passionate about the crafts, which he took up with his own hands in his leisure hours. In Naples he met a city with the same taste right across the social scale, from the nobility to the ordinary people. The court threw itself into the custom. Add to that the enthusiastic preaching of a hugely popular Dominican friar, Padre Rocco, to a people enjoying their newly won political independence.
The result was a craze. Jewellers, goldsmiths, musical instrument makers, potters, wax modellers and woodcarvers set about recreating in miniature everything a whole people needs to live, with help from the royal factories. In convents and at the palace, tiny costumes were sewn, fabrics embroidered and lace applied, with the queen herself at work. Almost every Neapolitan sculptor modelled nativity figures. The best came from the school of Giuseppe Sanmartino, who carved the Veiled Christ in the Sansevero Chapel. Others specialised: Giuseppe De Luca became famous for his poultry and still lifes, and several animal sculptors also worked at the royal porcelain factory.
What's left of those eighteenth-century nativity scenes?
The pieces, not the displays. Those great ensembles, often designed by architects and painters, lasted only a few weeks before they were taken apart. What has come down to us are the individual figures, which the 1935 encyclopaedia considered, by then by common consent, the finest Neapolitan sculpture of their century. Its explanation is intriguing: for the presepe, artists forgot about schools and academies, took nature as their teacher and found their models among living people.
The great age ended as the nineteenth century dawned. The court kept supporting the custom, under Murat and under the Bourbons, but the other half was missing: the people. A revival backed by Ferdinand II in 1843 found no echo, and by the middle of the nineteenth century the custom had all but disappeared. By 1935 the encyclopaedia could already see signs of a comeback.
What's the link with Spain? The Prince's Nativity Scene
A strong one. In 1759, Charles inherited the Spanish throne, abdicated the crown of Naples in favour of his eight-year-old son Ferdinand, and sailed for his new kingdom. His passion for the presepe went with him. Patrimonio Nacional, the body that runs Spain's royal palaces, explains that the so-called Belén del Príncipe, the Prince's Nativity Scene, which it keeps at the Royal Palace in Madrid, goes back to Charles III, who, fascinated by eighteenth-century Neapolitan life and culture, brought this nativity scene to Spain. More than eighty of its original figures survive, joined in 2001 by newly acquired Neapolitan ones.
Why is San Gregorio Armeno the nativity-scene street?
Because of its workshops. It's one of the narrow lanes linking the two main streets of the historic centre, Spaccanapoli and Via dei Tribunali, which follow the layout of the Greek city of Neapolis, and it's known as the street of nativity scenes because it's lined with craftsmen who make and sell the figures.
Since when? Nothing we've read says. There's a story going round that the street once had a temple of Ceres where people left clay votive offerings, and that this is where the craft began, but we haven't found any source to back it up. So it stays what it is: a story people tell. If you like Neapolitan traditions with more faith than paperwork behind them, the blood of San Gennaro is another good way into the city.
Fact or legend.
- Fact: Charles of Bourbon, later Charles III of Spain, made the presepe a passion at court, and the queen sewed clothes for the figures (Enciclopedia Italiana, 1935).
- But: he didn't invent it. By the early eighteenth century the Neapolitan presepe already had its typical form, and clay heads with glass eyes date from the late seventeenth.
- Fact: the sculptors took living people as their models, especially country people, in their own clothes.
- Fact: the great displays lasted a few weeks; only the figures survive.
- Fact: Patrimonio Nacional traces Madrid's Prince's Nativity Scene back to Charles III.
- No evidence: that the street's craft comes from a temple of Ceres, or for how long there have been workshops in San Gregorio Armeno.
Where to hear it
Podtour tells this story at the top of the street, at the stop "A King and His Shepherds" on the route The Historic Centre, Layer by Layer, eleven stops along Spaccanapoli and Via dei Tribunali.
If you're planning your trip, the Naples guide has the practical side covered.
Further reading
- Enciclopedia Italiana, "Presepio", Istituto della Enciclopedia Italiana, 1935 (Treccani, in Italian). https://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/presepio_(Enciclopedia-Italiana)/
- Enciclopedia Italiana, "Carlo III di Borbone, re di Spagna", 1931 (Treccani, in Italian). https://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/carlo-iii-di-borbone-re-di-spagna_(Enciclopedia-Italiana)/
- Alessandro D'Alfonso, "Sanmartino, Giuseppe", Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, vol. 90, 2017 (Treccani, in Italian). https://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/giuseppe-sanmartino_(Dizionario-Biografico)/
- Patrimonio Nacional, "El Belén del Príncipe: el desafío de recrear un mundo de detalles" (in Spanish). https://www.patrimonionacional.es/sites/default/files/documents/El%20Bel%C3%A9n%20del%20Pr%C3%ADncipe%2C%20el%20desaf%C3%ADo%20de%20recrear%20un%20mundo%20de%20detalles%20.pdf
Explore with Podtour
Where to hear this story
