Is it Pedro IV or Maximilian of Mexico? The Rossio statue
The short answer: it's Pedro IV, King of Portugal and the first Emperor of Brazil. The legend doing the rounds in Lisbon says the bronze figure on top of the column was made for Maximilian, the Emperor of Mexico who was shot in 1867, and that the city seized the chance and kept it. There isn't a single document to back it up, and the statue is holding the evidence against it: Portugal's Constitutional Charter. On top of that, Lisbon chose the design in a competition held in 1864 and approved it in 1866, before Maximilian died. What does have a history, and a rich one, is the rumour itself: where it came from, and why it's still going a century and a half later.

What does the Rossio legend say?
There are three versions, and each has its charm. In the first, the statue was travelling by ship to Mexico, put in at Lisbon just as news of the emperor's death arrived, and the city council, which had wanted to honour Pedro for years, noticed the resemblance and bought it. In the second, two statues crossed paths in the port and someone swapped them: Maximilian went up on the Rossio column and Pedro ended up in Mexico. In the third, the sculptor had the emperor gathering dust in a corner of his Paris studio, gave him a few touches and shipped him off to Lisbon.
A 2023 study that took the rumour very seriously points out something curious. For more than a century, the legend travelled by word of mouth alone, and whenever it did reach print, it was in articles debunking it. The first person to give it a push in writing, with plenty of irony, was the novelist José Cardoso Pires, in a 1997 book about Lisbon. Pedro or Maximilian? He didn't much mind: either way, the square got one more story to keep itself amused.
Who was Pedro IV, and why is he up there?
Pedro (1798–1834) declared Brazil's independence in 1822 and became its first emperor. In 1826 he also became King of Portugal, but he couldn't wear both crowns. So on 29 April that year he gave the country a Constitutional Charter, and shortly afterwards he abdicated in favour of his daughter. He was King of Portugal for about two months. Then came the war against his brother Miguel, the absolutist, and Pedro won it.
The Rossio had been the liberals' symbolic square since the revolution of 1820, and after Pedro's death it was decided the monument would be his. It took some doing. Competitions in 1841 and 1850 came to nothing, and for years the middle of the square was taken up by a pedestal with no statue, which Lisbon people called the galheteiro, the cruet stand. Finally, in 1864, an international competition drew 87 entries, judged blind, without the designers' names. The winners were two Parisians: the architect Gabriel Davioud and the sculptor Élias Robert.
The foundation stone was laid on 29 April 1867. The statue was hoisted into place on 11 April 1870, and the monument was unveiled on 29 April, the anniversary of the Charter. Up there, some 27 metres above the ground, Pedro wears a laurel wreath and a royal mantle and holds the Charter in his right hand. Below, four female figures stand for Fortitude, Moderation, Prudence and Justice.
Why can't it be Maximilian?
Start with what's in his hand: the Charter, the constitution Pedro himself gave Portugal. It's his calling card, and the whole point of the monument.
Then there are the dates. Maximilian of Habsburg arrived in Mexico in 1864, the same year as the Lisbon competition. He was captured in May 1867 and shot at Querétaro on 19 June. By then, Lisbon's design had been approved since 1866, it had gone on public display with all the other entries, and building work had already begun. Photographs of all 87 entries show that the winner is exactly what you see in the Rossio. And in December 1868, a Paris newspaper reported that the statue of Pedro had been cast. Maximilian had been dead for a year and a half.
The Museu de Lisboa put it bluntly in 2020: it's an urban myth that the city has repeated time and again.
Where did the rumour come from?
Nobody knows who started it. The author of the 2023 study, the researcher Jorge Artur dos Santos, reconstructs the atmosphere instead, and it was perfect for a joke like this.
Pedro had enemies. To the supporters of his brother, the Miguelites, he was the traitor who'd lost Brazil. Their newspaper, A Nação, mocked the monument from start to finish. The day after the unveiling, it compared the column to a candlestick and the king to its wick, and it had fun with the four Ps on the base: "Pedro Pôs Portugal Pedindo", Pedro left Portugal begging. Santos thinks the rumour most likely started in those circles.
But they weren't alone. Even the monument's committee wasn't wildly enthusiastic: five of its twelve voting members preferred other designs, and the author of the official account of 1870 admitted it wouldn't be short of critics. A French critic poked fun at the king balancing on half a globe. And the novelist Eça de Queiroz wrote in 1872 that Pedro was passing into posterity with a roll of paper in his hand, like a notary, with nothing about him to suggest a soldier.
And Maximilian was fresh news: the Lisbon papers had followed his downfall week by week. The monument's designers were French, and France had propped up the emperor in Mexico before pulling its troops out. The physical resemblance, according to Santos, came down to one detail: both men had beards, and from down below that's about all you can make out. There's a family thread too. Maximilian was a cousin of Pedro II of Brazil, Pedro's son, and he'd fallen in love with one of the king's daughters, Maria Amélia, who died young.
What was hidden under the column?
This part is confirmed. In April 1870, as the king was being raised onto the column, the son of one of the master stonemasons on the job slipped some glass jars containing written accounts into the base. They came to light in 2001, when the square was being redone, and the Museu de Lisboa looks after them. According to the 2023 study, one had lost its contents, apparently a photograph; the other still held two handwritten papers, one about the laying of the foundation stone and one about the morning the statue went up.
Fact or legend.
- Legend: that the statue was made for Maximilian of Mexico and that Lisbon bought it or swapped it. It spread by word of mouth; in print, for over a century, almost only to be debunked.
- Fact: the statue represents Pedro IV and holds the Constitutional Charter of 1826. The design came from a competition held in 1864 and was approved in 1866; by December 1868 the statue had been cast, and it was unveiled on 29 April 1870.
- Fact: Maximilian was shot on 19 June 1867, when Lisbon's design was already approved and work had started.
- Hypothesis: that the rumour began among the Miguelites is the most likely explanation according to the 2023 study, not a proven fact. Who actually started it, nobody knows.
Where to hear it
The legend is told at the foot of the column, at the stop "An emperor in Rossio?", the last one on Lisbon's free route, Lisbon's Baixa: from Terreiro do Paço to the Rossio, eleven stops up from the river. The route begins in front of another bronze king, José I on horseback, at the stop "Raze it, then reach for a ruler", and that's no coincidence: he's Pedro's great-grandfather.
If you'd like more of the Rossio, the black-and-white waves in the paving have a story of their own, and the route's other myth is the one about the Santa Justa Lift and Eiffel. This king's heart, by the way, isn't in Lisbon: he left it to Porto in his will, and the stop "A heart behind five locks" tells that story. For the practical side of your trip, see our Lisbon guide.
Further reading
- Jorge Artur dos Santos, 'Memórias em conflito: a disputa de significados em torno do monumento a Pedro IV em Lisboa', Cadernos do Arquivo Municipal, 2nd series, no. 19 (2023), Lisbon City Council (in Portuguese). https://doi.org/10.48751/CAM-2023-19238
- Bruno Horta, 'Estátua de D. Pedro IV em Lisboa faz 150 anos e há documentos inéditos que falam da inauguração', Observador, 15 July 2020 (in Portuguese). https://observador.pt/2020/07/15/estatua-de-d-pedro-iv-em-lisboa-faz-150-anos-e-ha-documentos-ineditos-que-falam-da-inauguracao/
- Centro Nacional de Cultura, 'Estátua do Rei D. Pedro IV', e-cultura (in Portuguese). https://www.e-cultura.pt/patrimonio_item/2974
Explore with Podtour
Where to hear this story
