The face on the wall of the Palazzo Vecchio: did Michelangelo carve it?

The short answer: nobody knows. On one of the stone blocks of the Palazzo Vecchio's façade there's a man's profile carved into the stone, and Florentine tradition says Michelangelo did it. Tradition tells the story four different ways, but we haven't found a single early source to back it up. In 2020, an art historian suggested the tradition might be right after all: he compared the face with a drawing in the Louvre on which Michelangelo himself had written "Who would ever say that it was by my hand?", and proposed that it portrays a friend of his, the painter Francesco Granacci. It's a serious hypothesis, but a hypothesis all the same. The specialists don't agree.

A man's profile carved into a stone block on the façade of the Palazzo Vecchio, beside the door, in Florence

Where is the face on the Palazzo Vecchio?

On the main façade, the one facing Piazza della Signoria. Stand in front of the palace's great doorway: on your left is the copy of Michelangelo's David; on your right, the marble group of Hercules and Cacus. Just behind Hercules, on the wall, towards the corner with Via della Ninna, is the profile: a forehead, a strong nose, a chin. Florentines call it l'Importuno or l'Inopportuno, the nuisance.

It's carved in pietraforte, the brownish stone of the façade, which wears away in the weather. It's easy to walk straight past it.

What does the legend of the Importuno say?

The best-known version explains the nickname. Michelangelo often crossed the square, and time and again the same man would waylay him with a list of his woes. In some tellings he was a debtor, explaining over and over why he couldn't pay the money back yet. One day, fed up, the artist pretended to listen, took out his chisel and, with his hands behind his back, carved the man's face into the wall behind him. Revenge without a word.

There's more. In another version, the debtor was locked in the pillory in the square. Michelangelo asked the guards how long he'd be kept there, decided it wasn't nearly long enough and set the face in stone so that Florentines would never forget not to lend him money. The third version is about a bet: he was challenged to carve a self-portrait without a mirror and with his hands behind his back. And the fourth changes the mood completely: during an execution, the artist was so struck by the condemned man's expression that, with no paper to hand, he scratched it into the wall in a hurry.

How old is the story?

We don't know, and that's the first thing to say. We've read all four versions in recent local publications, which tell them as legends. We haven't found the first time anyone wrote them down, or any account from Michelangelo's own day. Even the historian who studied the face says the carving's origin is obscure and that crediting it to Michelangelo comes from an old popular legend.

Notice, too, that the four stories don't fit together. The man in the portrait is a nuisance, a debtor, a condemned prisoner or Michelangelo himself. All they share is the artist, and that's usually a sign the explanation was dreamt up later, to fit the face. It's the same with the other stone face on this walk, Berta, on the bell tower of Santa Maria Maggiore: legends to suit every taste, and no birth certificate.

What does the Louvre drawing show?

This is where the documented part begins. The Louvre holds a sheet attributed to Michelangelo with three drawings on it: a group of the Virgin, the Christ Child and Saint Anne, a study of a male nude, and a small profile of a man that scholars had largely ignored. Beside the profile, in his own hand, the artist wrote "Chi dire mai chella f[osse] di mia mano": who would ever say that it was by my hand?

Adriano Marinazzo, a curator at the Muscarelle Museum of Art at William & Mary in Virginia, came across that profile while preparing an exhibition and saw how closely it resembled the face on the Palazzo Vecchio. He overlaid the digital outlines of the two profiles on a computer and published his proposal in 2020 in the Italian journal Art e Dossier. By his account, it's the first scholarly study of the face.

His argument rests on three points. The style matches the profiles Michelangelo was drawing in the early sixteenth century. The façade of the seat of government was always guarded, so whoever carved it did so with the authorities' permission, not on the sly. And the date he proposes, around 1504, coincides with the arrival of David at the palace door, which, he says, is where the profile is looking. Marinazzo admitted it took nerve to publish: with a figure like Michelangelo you have to be careful, he said, but "sometimes it is worth daring".

Who was Francesco Granacci?

If Marinazzo is right, the face isn't a nuisance at all, but a friend. Giorgio Vasari gave Granacci a chapter of his own in the 1568 edition of his Lives of the Artists. He says the two crossed paths as boys in the garden where Lorenzo de' Medici sent young artists to learn, and in Domenico Ghirlandaio's workshop. Granacci, Vasari writes, saw Michelangelo's talent from boyhood and stuck by his side, and Michelangelo loved him more than any other friend. Years later he was among the first Michelangelo called to help with the frescoes on the Sistine Chapel ceiling, though in the end, unhappy with all of them, Michelangelo shut the door on them and they went back to Florence. Granacci died in 1544, aged sixty-seven.

There's one more detail. According to Marinazzo and the press that reported his study, Granacci sat on the committee of artists, alongside Leonardo and Botticelli, that was to choose where David should stand. The statue reached the square in May 1504 and was set up at the palace door in June, in the spot where Donatello's Judith had stood. The original was moved to the Galleria dell'Accademia in 1873; what you see by the door is a copy. If Marinazzo has it right, the friend who helped choose the giant's spot ended up carved into the wall beside it.

So did Michelangelo carve it?

Maybe, but it isn't proven. In favour, there's the likeness to a drawing by his hand and that very tempting note. Against, or at least unresolved: the note doesn't mention any wall, a likeness is always open to argument, and there's no document that refers to the carving. The press coverage of his proposal put it plainly: scholars are divided.

What we do know is that someone carved a face into the most closely guarded wall in Florence, that the city has spent generations crediting it to its most famous artist and that, for now, the profile is keeping its secret. Close by, on the same walk, another Florentine tradition asks you to rub the snout of a bronze boar: here's why people rub the Porcellino's nose.

Fact or legend.

  • Fact: there's a man's profile carved into the façade of the Palazzo Vecchio, to the right of the door.
  • Legend: that Michelangelo carved it to mock a nuisance, a debtor or a condemned man, or to win a bet. Four versions; no early source found.
  • Fact: the Louvre holds a sheet attributed to Michelangelo with a similar profile and the note "Who would ever say that it was by my hand?".
  • Hypothesis: that the face is by Michelangelo, from around 1504, and portrays Francesco Granacci (Adriano Marinazzo, 2020). Specialists are divided.
  • Fact: Granacci was a close friend of Michelangelo's from youth, according to Vasari.

Where to hear it

Podtour tells this story in front of the palace, at the stop "The face scratched into the wall", the last on the route Legends of Florence, which begins, fittingly, with another stone face, "Who was Berta?". A little earlier, at the Mercato Nuovo, you'll hear "The boar with the shiny snout".

If you're planning your trip, the Florence guide has the practical side covered.

Further reading

Explore with Podtour

Where to hear this story

Keep exploring

Plan your time in Florence

Explore FlorenceTravel guide

Take the stories
with you.

Download Podtour for free and start with the free walk in every city. Your pace, your next stop.