The church hidden in an Amsterdam attic

The short answer: in a house on the Oudezijds Voorburgwal canal, in the heart of old Amsterdam, there's a complete Catholic church tucked under the roof. A merchant called Jan Hartman joined up the attics of three houses and opened it in 1663, with room for around a hundred and fifty people. It's known as Ons' Lieve Heer op Solder, Our Lord in the Attic. It existed because, from 1578, Catholics weren't allowed to hold Mass in public. And the oddest thing isn't that it was hidden. It's that the authorities knew perfectly well where it was.

Narrow 17th-century canal house in Amsterdam that hides a complete Catholic church in its attic

Why were there hidden churches in Amsterdam?

It all starts with Amsterdam changing sides. The city was slow to join William of Orange against the King of Spain, and when it finally did, in May 1578, not a drop of blood was spilt: the Catholic magistrates were put on barges and dropped off on a dyke outside town. What changed overnight were the churches. They passed to the Protestants, among them St Nicholas's, which the city had been calling the Oude Kerk, the Old Church, since the fifteenth century.

In the new Dutch Republic, public worship was reserved for the Reformed Church, the Calvinists. Catholics, Lutherans, Mennonites and Remonstrants weren't persecuted for what they believed, but they couldn't practise their faith in full view. The group that worried the authorities most was the Catholics: they were linked with Spain, which the Republic was at war with until 1648, and they answered to a foreign ruler, the Pope.

So Catholics prayed at home. At first in private rooms that kept changing, with only the bare essentials, easy to clear away if officials turned up. From around 1620, in fixed places. And over the years, in proper churches slotted inside ordinary buildings.

Were they secret churches?

No, and that's the clever part. At the time, everyone knew where they were. The Dutch word now used for them, schuilkerk ("hiding church"), was coined in the nineteenth century, when historians liked to picture them as clandestine refuges. But the Republic's rulers didn't mind these churches existing; they minded them being seen. So the rules were all about appearances: no towers, and the church preferably set behind other houses or given a house front.

Town councils quickly realised that a harsh crackdown was neither wise nor enforceable, so they chose to look the other way. In 1651, the States General put it in writing: these communities, Catholics included, were quietly allowed to carry on wherever they already were. The museum now in Hartman's house sums it up neatly: "Behind the front door everyone is allowed to think and believe whatever they want."

The same rule applied at the Begijnhof, the courtyard of the beguines. The city let them have a new chapel on condition that, seen from the street, nobody would take it for a church. They built it inside two houses.

Who built the church in the attic?

Jan Hartman came from Coesfeld, in Germany, and in Amsterdam he worked his way up from baker's apprentice to prosperous merchant. He wasn't noble, but he liked to look the part: over the fireplace in his grand salon he had a coat of arms carved, with a resting deer for his surname and a compass because his wife Elisabeth's father was a compass maker.

On 10 May 1661 he bought the canal house along with the two houses behind it, on an alley. He rebuilt all three and joined the attics into one enormous space. You didn't reach the church from the canal: you came in through a side door on the alley, the Heintje Hoekssteeg, and climbed flight after flight of stairs. Just before the top, a holy water basin set into the wall let worshippers cross themselves before going in.

The name is a bit of a muddle. According to the museum, the church was named after the man who built it and called Het Hart. A study by Museum Catharijneconvent and the Dutch heritage agency calls it Het Hert. Both forms echo Hartman's surname, and we haven't been able to establish which one is the original.

What's the church like inside?

On the outside, nothing. On the inside, everything that couldn't be shown in the street: many hidden churches made up for their plain fronts with Baroque interiors full of altars, silver and paintings. In Hartman's, the Baroque altar is the star, and it has a trick that tells you everything about the lack of space: the base of one of its columns folds out to become a pulpit. The altarpiece, a Baptism of Christ, was painted by Jacob de Wit in 1716, long after Hartman's day, and could be swapped for other scenes through the church year.

Who said Mass there?

Hartman rented the church to Petrus Parmentier, an Augustinian friar from Ghent who'd arrived in Protestant Amsterdam in 1636 with orders to win people over to the Catholic faith. He started out renting a room on the Zeedijk and saying Mass in Catholic homes, with the help of the so-called spiritual daughters: unmarried women who gave their lives to prayer and good works, and of whom there were more than five thousand in the Republic. In 1662 he moved, with them, into one of the houses on the alley.

The congregation flourished. In 1667 alone, seventy children were baptised in the attic and fourteen weddings were held there.

What became of Hartman and his church?

Hartman barely got to enjoy it. He died in April 1668 and was buried on the 25th in the Oude Kerk, the old Catholic church that by then was Protestant, and at his widow's request the bells tolled for three hours. He left heavy debts: in 1670 Parmentier had to move out, and a few years later the family had to give up the house.

The church, though, stayed put. When freedom of religion arrived, around 1800, congregations wanted churches that could be seen from the street, and most of the hidden ones were replaced between 1825 and 1875. This one was luckier. In 1888 a historical society, the Amstelkring, became the first in the Netherlands to champion one of these churches and set about saving it; the museum grew out of that. Of the thousands there must have been in the Republic, a 2022 study counted only twenty-eight with their interiors reasonably intact.

From the street, the house still looks like any other squeezed in along the canals. If you've ever wondered why they're so narrow and why some of them lean, we explain it in Why are Amsterdam's houses crooked?.

Fact or legend?

  • Fact: from 1578 Catholics couldn't hold Mass in public, and churches in private houses were tolerated.
  • Fact: Hartman bought the house in 1661, joined three attics, and the church opened in 1663, with room for about 150 people.
  • Nuance: hidden, yes; secret, no. The authorities knew where these churches were, and the word schuilkerk only dates from the nineteenth century.
  • Disputed: the original name. Het Hart according to the museum; Het Hert according to the Catharijneconvent and heritage agency study.
  • No evidence: that worshippers said "I'm off to the parrot" to tip each other off about Mass. It does the rounds online, but it isn't on the museum's website or in any source we've been able to read.
  • Legend: the tunnel under a canal said to have linked another hidden church, De Posthoorn, with the corner house at the Papeneiland. Even the diocese calls it a "supposed" passage.

Where to hear it

Hartman's story is told near the house, at the stop "A Church Hidden in the Attic" on the route "The Red-Light District and the Old Harbour", thirteen stops between Centraal Station and the Nieuwmarkt. The beguines' chapel rounds off the free route "From the Dam to the Begijnhof", at "The Last Catholic Courtyard". And the tunnel has a stop of its own, "The Papists' Tunnel", on "The Jordaan: Courtyards, Warehouses and Uprisings".

If you're planning your trip, the practical side is in our Amsterdam guide.

Further reading

Explore with Podtour

Where to hear this story

Keep exploring

Plan your time in Amsterdam

Explore AmsterdamTravel guide

Take the stories
with you.

Download Podtour for free and start with the free walk in every city. Your pace, your next stop.