Why was Gaudí arrested?
The short answer: because he tried to go to Mass in a church the police had shut. It happened on 11 September 1924, while General Primo de Rivera ruled Spain as dictator. The authorities had closed Barcelona's churches to stop people marking the Diada, Catalonia's national day, and Antoni Gaudí, then seventy-two, tried to get into the basilica of Sants Just i Pastor, where a Mass had been planned for those who died in 1714. A policeman blocked his way, Gaudí stood his ground in Catalan, and he ended up in a police station along with another churchgoer. There he was accused of insulting the officers, which he denied, and the row turned into an argument about language. Almost everything we know comes from a single account written at the time, with no name attached.

What happened on 11 September 1924?
The eleventh of September is the Diada, the day Barcelona honours those who died defending the city in 1714. In 1924 Spain was under Primo de Rivera's dictatorship, and that morning the city's churches were found shut on the authorities' orders. The idea was to stop Masses for the fallen of 1714 from turning into Diada gatherings.
One of those Masses had been announced at the basilica of Sants Just i Pastor, Saints Justus and Pastor, a very old church on a quiet little square in the Gothic Quarter. There were police outside its doors.
How was Gaudí arrested?
The account gives the time with a police report's precision: five past eight in the morning. The first to arrive is a man named Valls. A policeman asks him where he's going; he says, in Catalan, that he's going to Mass; the officer tells him, in Spanish, that he can't go in and should try another church, or the other door. Valls tries the door on Carrer de la Ciutat. Another policeman, another refusal, another argument.
At that point Gaudí turns up, the man who was building the Sagrada Família, and heads for the entrance without a moment's hesitation. He gets the same question and gives the same answer. When he's told he can't go in, he replies that he will. The policeman grabs him by the arm. Valls comes to his defence, and the pair of them are taken into custody at the police station on Plaça del Regomir, just round the corner.
Was Gaudí arrested for speaking Catalan?
That's how it's usually told, but the account is more nuanced. He was speaking Catalan at the door, it's true, and being answered in Spanish. But what triggers the arrest, according to the text, is his determination to get into a church that had been shut. When the two men are brought into the station, the policeman also accuses them of insulting him, and Gaudí flatly denies it. The language row comes later, during questioning.
Four officers take his statement. Name: Antoni Gaudí. Age: seventy-one, he says. Profession: architect. And then one of them tells him that, as an architect, his profession obliges him to speak Spanish. Gaudí replies, in Catalan, that what his profession obliges him to do is pay his taxes, which he does, and not to give up his own language. From there, things turn nasty: one of the policemen goes as far as telling him that if he weren't so old, he'd smash his face in.
And in the middle of all that, a neighbour rushes in, flustered. She's heard that Mr Gaudí has been arrested on his way to Sant Just, and she's sure he won't have had any breakfast yet. Valls persuades the officers to let her go and fetch him something. She comes back with a bottle of milk, a glass, a Vienna roll and a spoon, all wrapped up in a napkin. And Gaudí, under arrest and with the officers making fun of him, has his breakfast.
Then the two men are sent on to another police office, at the Llotja, the old exchange building. There the scene repeats itself almost word for word. Valls now speaks Spanish to defend Gaudí's right to speak Catalan, and the chief seizes on it: you see how your companion speaks Spanish? Gaudí answers that yes, he can see that, but his own language is quite enough for him: "jo en tinc prou amb la meva llengua".
So the honest answer has two parts. He was arrested for trying to get into a closed church, and at the station he was also accused of an insult that he denied. What turned that morning into a famous story was his refusal to switch languages.
How long was Gaudí held?
We don't know for sure. The account ends at the Llotja and doesn't say how things finished. A later popular website, which cites no sources, says he was held for about four hours and released after paying a fine of fifty pesetas, and that the next day he told a colleague about it, indignant and convinced it had all been because he spoke Catalan. That may be so, but it's a later version and we've found no document to back it up.
Who wrote the account of the arrest?
Nobody knows. The text circulates as a record kept in Barcelona's archive, the Arxiu de Barcelona, and it was shared again for the centenary, but its author isn't recorded. That's why it should be read with care: it's clearly written from the side of the two men arrested, and its dialogue isn't a recording.
It also has a couple of details that don't quite add up. Gaudí gives his age as seventy-one, but he was born on 25 June 1852, so he was seventy-two. And one recent newspaper piece dates the arrest to 1923; the account itself and the other sources we've read all put it in 1924.
Fact or legend.
- Fact: on 11 September 1924 the authorities shut Barcelona's churches to prevent Diada gatherings, and the police arrested Gaudí as he tried to get into Sants Just i Pastor.
- Contemporary account, author unknown: the time, the scuffle, the accusation of insults, the line about taxes, the breakfast and the transfer to the Llotja.
- Later version, no source given: the four hours in custody and the fifty-peseta fine.
- Oversimplified: "he was arrested for speaking Catalan". Catalan was there from the moment he reached the door and it was at the heart of the row in the station, but according to the account, what triggered the arrest was his insistence on entering a closed church.
Where to hear it
It's told on the square, facing the church door, at the stop "The morning Gaudí was arrested" on The Gothic Quarter: Saints, Kings and the Call, Podtour's free route in Barcelona: eleven stops in just over a kilometre.
Gaudí's great work has a story of its own: why the Sagrada Família is taking so long. And if you like churches whose legend isn't quite what it seems, the Born has Santa Maria del Mar and the bastaixos.
If you're planning your trip, the Barcelona guide has the practical side covered.
Further reading
- Diari de Tarragona, "Antoni Gaudí ja és venerable: què vol dir?", 14 April 2025 (transcribes the 1924 account, in Catalan). https://www.diaridetarragona.com/reus/229013/antoni-gaudi-ja-es-venerable-que-vol-dir-op23681708.html
- Roger Palós, "Cien años desde que Gaudí fue detenido por hablar en catalán en la Diada", Ara, 11 September 2024. https://es.ara.cat/politica/cien-anos-gaudi-detenido-hablar-catalan-diada_1_5136048.html
- "Antoni Gaudí i Cornet", Gran Enciclopèdia Catalana. https://www.enciclopedia.cat/gran-enciclopedia-catalana/antoni-gaudi-i-cornet
Explore with Podtour
Where to hear this story
